Add atomic signal selectors to Kea
Introduce fine-grained atomic selector tracking with dependency health, circular detection, and unchanged Kea lifecycle behavior.
kea-atomic-signal-selectors
Normalized profile
What this task asks for
Introduce fine-grained atomic selector tracking with dependency health, circular detection, and unchanged Kea lifecycle behavior. Propagation: Support multi-level selector chains where updates propagate only to affected selectors. If a selector's inputs haven't changed, it should not re-evaluate. Circular Safety: Detect and prevent circular dependency loops **during the logic mounting/building phase**. When a loop is detected, the engine must throw an error containing the exact string: `[KEA] Circular dependency detected`. Compatibility: Ensure all baseline Kea behaviors (lifecycle events, mounting order) remain unchanged. The new engine intercepts core lifecycle hooks; valid implementations must ensure that standard plugin event ordering (e.g., `afterMount`) is not disrupted. React Integration: Components must re-render only when their accessed state or derived selectors change. Unrelated state updates must not trigger re-renders. When `atomicSelectors` is true, expose `logic.selectorHealth()` as a function. When disabled, `logic.selectorHealth` must be `undefined`.
Intent
- feature implementation
- configuration tuning
- test and validation
Work surfaces
- configuration
- renderer
- library API
- build system
Technology
- Kea
Expected artifacts
- repository patch
What makes it difficult
- concurrency, cancellation, or distributed-state coordination
- strict behavioral compatibility or exact-output validation
- composite state and lifecycle-transition semantics
- specialized algorithmic or domain reasoning
- changes span multiple components or interfaces
Published evidence
Model × harness outcomes
Counts are tied to these exact configurations. Harnesses are not treated as equivalent across benchmarks.
- Models
- 13
- Configurations
- 41
- Trials
- 164
Showing 41 of 41 configurations
| Model | Harness | Effort | Result | Passes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| claude-fable-5vertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | Mixed | 2/4 |
| claude-fable-5vertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | Mixed | 1/4 |
| claude-fable-5vertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | No passes | 0/4 |
| claude-fable-5vertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | Mixed | 1/4 |
| claude-fable-5vertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | No passes | 0/4 |
| claude-opus-4-8anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | Mixed | 3/4 |
| claude-opus-4-8anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | Mixed | 3/4 |
| claude-opus-4-8anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 2/4 |
| claude-opus-4-8anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | Mixed | 1/4 |
| claude-opus-4-8anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | No passes | 0/4 |
| claude-sonnet-4-6anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | No passes | 0/4 |
| claude-sonnet-5anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | Mixed | 2/4 |
| claude-sonnet-5anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | Mixed | 2/4 |
| claude-sonnet-5anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 1/4 |
| claude-sonnet-5anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | No passes | 0/4 |
| claude-sonnet-5anthropic | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | No passes | 0/4 |
| gemini-3-1-pro-previewvertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | No passes | 0/4 |
| gemini-3-5-flashvertex_ai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | No passes | 0/4 |
| glm-5-2zai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 1/4 |
| glm-5-2zai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | Mixed | 2/4 |
| gpt-5-4openai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-5openai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-5openai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-5openai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-5openai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-6-lunaopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-lunaopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-lunaopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-lunaopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-lunaopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-solopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-6-solopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-6-solopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-6-solopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | All passed | 4/4 |
| gpt-5-6-solopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | Mixed | 3/4 |
| gpt-5-6-terraopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | low | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-terraopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | medium | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-terraopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | high | Mixed | 2/4 |
| gpt-5-6-terraopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | xhigh | No passes | 0/4 |
| gpt-5-6-terraopenai | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | max | Mixed | 1/4 |
| kimi-k2-7-codeopenrouter | mini-swe-agentpublished configuration | default | No passes | 0/4 |